ASTR 204 Home

Debate Assignments

The format for the in-class debates will be a 15 minute presentation by the pros, followed by a 15 minute presentation by the cons, followed by 5 minutes of rebuttal for either side. The last 10 minutes of class will be a general discussion and question period involving the entire class. At the end of the discussion, the class will vote on the winner of the debate.

To check which of the eight debate groups to which you belong look below: (note this list is in alphabetical order except for 2 students as indicated)
 
 

DEBATE GROUPS (students listed from A to Z OF LAST NAME)

GROUP #1 Michael A. Raymon Jennifer Kristopher Roxanne Rebecca Ryan Wade Ryan

GROUP #2 Meghan C. Joseph Aaron Lisette Ryan Robb Melissa Micah Jacob

GROUP #3 Jessie G. Alison Dathon Audelia Lacey Brittany Shayna Gilbert Mark

GROUP #4 Charles K. Lyndsey Lindsay Kristen Raymond Dylan Keanan (Haley T. - added out of Alphabetical order) (Joe M. - added out of Alphabetical order)

GROUP #5 Andrew L. Nicole Benjamin Lauren Elizabeth Timothy Timothy Robert Edward Eileen

GROUP #6 Richard P. James Aaron Jason Thomas Eric Roxanne Melissa Tiia (Jen L. - added out of Alphabetical order)

GROUP #7 Aron S. Elisa Maulik Craig Asa Jennifer David Jason Katie

GROUP #8 Jonathon S. Michael Hannah Kelly Krista Andrew Michael Faham (Nicholas K. & Nathaniel K. - added out of Alphabetical order)
 
 

The debate assignments are as follows:

#1: The dinosaurs died when another body impacted the Earth. Group 8 (pro) vs. Group 4 (con).

#2: Most dark matter is in the form of non-baryons. Group 1 (pro) vs. Group 3 (con).

#3: The Moon formed by a collision of the Earth with another body. Group 7 (pro) vs. Group 5 (con).

#4: There is other intelligent life in the Universe. Group 6 (pro) vs. Group 2 (con).